The Map Problem
From the outset, the map in "Return to Moria" seems designed more as a stumbling block than a navigation tool. It's not intuitive, and what could be a simple query to orient yourself ends up becoming a frustrating exercise. This wouldn't be a problem if it were aligned with the game's narrative, and here's where the lore comes in.
In Tolkien's mythology, dwarves have an almost instinctive knowledge of underground structures. They don't need a map because their familiarity with Moria's paths is etched in their memory. While this logical script could justify a complicated map for the player, the reality is that this decision makes the experience unfriendly, especially for those new to this type of game.
A Vertical Learning Curve
The map is not only difficult to interpret but also forces you to face an almost vertical learning curve. This isn't a game where you "eventually understand" how things work; it's a game where you need to struggle to adapt. The presentation of levels and how they interconnect is confusing. Moria is a vertical city by nature, and that is reflected in the map design. However, what could have become a challenging but rewarding element ends up being a source of frustration.
For example, the lack of clarity in the level system makes it challenging to find a coherent path to your objective. This not only affects immersion but also game efficiency. Instead of focusing on exploration, survival, and resource management, you spend a disproportionate amount of time trying to understand where you are and where you should go.
The Good and the Bad of the Design Decision
It's important to recognize that some may argue that this map design aligns with the spirit of the game. Perhaps the intention is to reflect the complexity and monumentality of Moria, making players feel like real explorers in a massive and labyrinthine structure. But, let's be honest, the execution fails to provide the player with the necessary tools to adapt without sacrificing enjoyment.
The level system could be fascinating if it were better explained. A good implementation would include clear landmarks, more details on the map, and a more user-friendly introductory guide for beginners.
My Proposal
To improve this aspect of the game, I would suggest the following solutions:
- Clear Indicators: Incorporate signs or visual landmarks that can be identified both on the map and in the game environment.
- Interactive Guide: An optional tutorial that explains how to interpret the map and how to move between levels.
- Map Layers: Create a layer system to better represent Moria's verticality, allowing easy switching between levels.
- Player Notes: A tool that allows players to add personal markers or notes on the map to better orient themselves.
Conclusion
"Lord of the Rings: Return to Moria" has a lot of potential, but its map is a weak point that needs attention. As a player who has spent countless hours in virtual worlds, I know that a good map can make all the difference between a frustrating game and an unforgettable one. While Tolkien's dwarves don't need maps, players do. And a game that strives to be immersive and challenging shouldn't lose sight of the importance of a good user experience.
Despite these criticisms, "Return to Moria" remains a unique experience, and I hope future updates can address this issue so that more people can fully enjoy what this game has to offer.